How Courts Sanction Lawyers for AI Hallucinated Citations, and What Immigration Lawyers Face

How Courts Sanction Lawyers for AI Hallucinated Citations, and What Immigration Lawyers Face

Author
Kier Dela Rosa
Last Updated
November 17, 2026

Courts sanction lawyers for AI hallucinated citations when a lawyer signs and files a brief with cases, quotations or holdings that nobody checked. The reported penalties run from a $1,000 fine to a six-month suspension. In immigration practice, a suspension can also reach the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).

None of these orders penalizes AI use itself. In Lnu v. Blanche, the Ninth Circuit named the violation as signing unverified briefs and then making false statements about them. The Fifth Circuit has said AI can help when lawyers use it with care.

This guide starts with the basics, moves through the rules, penalties and immigration cases, and ends with a check you can run before you sign.

Key Takeaways

  • Courts apply existing rules to the signed filing, mainly Rule 11, Appellate Rules 38 and 46 and their inherent authority. No order reviewed here relied on an AI-specific statute.
  • Reported penalties run from a $1,000 fine in Kaur v. Desso to a six-month suspension in Lnu v. Blanche. Whiting v. City of Athens added $15,000 per lawyer plus the other side's fees.
  • In the ten matters compared below, denials and silence drew the heaviest penalties, and prompt admissions drew lighter ones.
  • The signing lawyer answers for a filing someone else drafted, and Rule 11(c)(1) can make the firm jointly responsible.
  • A federal court suspension can reach immigration practice. In Matter of Sethi, 30 I&N Dec. 112 (BIA 2026), the Board of Immigration Appeals adopted the six-month suspension for practice before the Board, the immigration courts and DHS.

What an AI Hallucinated Citation Looks Like

A hallucinated citation is a reference that a generative AI tool states with confidence even though it does not match real authority. The orders in this guide describe three versions of it:

  • A case that does not exist, such as the two nonexistent cases in the Lnu opening brief.
  • A real case with a quotation it does not contain. The Kaur v. Desso brief attributed quotations to four real Supreme Court decisions, and the language is not in them. The court saw no reason to treat fabricated quotations differently from fabricated cases.
  • A real case cited for a point it does not support. The Fifth Circuit found one described as reversing a sanction when it affirmed one.

That third version is the hardest to catch because the citation resolves in a database. The Sixth Circuit observed in Whiting v. City of Athens that fake citations are more likely when no real authority supports the proposition being argued.

CLINIC tested the risk on an asylum question. A general-purpose chatbot cited Campbell v. Barr, 956 F.3d 542, 553 (2d Cir. 2020) for a firm-resettlement point. The author could not find the case in standard legal databases, and the chatbot later admitted it was fake. Details appear in a CLINIC practice advisory.

Why Courts Sanction the Signature on the Filing

With those three forms in mind, the next question is which rule a court applies. In every order reviewed here the answer is an existing rule, and the rule decides how a sanction starts.

The Rules Behind the Sanctions

None of the orders in this guide relied on a new AI statute. The courts used Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 in Mata and Kaur and Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 46 in Fletcher and Lnu. Whiting rested on Appellate Rule 38 and the court's inherent authority to police abuse of its process.

Signing a filing certifies it under Rule 11(b). Legal contentions must rest on existing law or a nonfrivolous argument to change it, and factual claims need evidentiary support. In Lnu, the Ninth Circuit also applied California Rules of Professional Conduct 1.1, 1.3, 3.1(a)(2) and 3.3(a)(1), which cover competence, diligence, meritorious claims and candor.

ABA Formal Opinion 512 (2024) reaches the same place from the ethics side. A Minnesota Office of Lawyers Professional Responsibility summary says AI output headed to a tribunal needs the same accuracy check as any other source. Our guide to attorney oversight of AI in immigration covers the opinion's six duties.

How a Sanction Starts

Rule 11(c) gives a sanction two starting points. The other side can serve a separate motion. It cannot be filed if the lawyer withdraws or corrects the challenged paper within 21 days of service. Alternatively, the court can act on its own by ordering the lawyer to show cause why specific conduct does not violate Rule 11(b).

Kaur v. Desso, No. 9:25-cv-726 (N.D.N.Y. July 9, 2025), took the second route. The court ordered the lawyer to show cause on June 24, 2025. It then found the subjective bad faith that the Second Circuit requires for court-initiated sanctions.

Appellate courts use a similar order. The Fifth Circuit's show-cause order in Fletcher v. Experian listed 16 fabricated quotations and five other serious misstatements of law or fact before the court imposed a sanction.

Sanctions Courts Have Ordered, by Type

Reported penalties fall into eight types, and one order can combine several of them.

Sanction Example Authority named
Fine paid to the court Mata v. Avianca, $5,000 jointly (S.D.N.Y. June 22, 2023); Fletcher v. Experian, $2,500 (5th Cir. Feb. 18, 2026); Kaur, $1,000; Whiting, $15,000 per lawyer (6th Cir. Mar. 13, 2026); Perez-Castillo v. Blanche, $5,000 (7th Cir. June 1, 2026) Rule 11, Appellate Rules 46(c) and 38, inherent authority
The other side's fees and costs Whiting: appellees' appellate fees in all three appeals, plus double costs Appellate Rule 38, inherent authority, 28 U.S.C. 1920
Corrective letters Mata: letters to the client and to each judge falsely named as the author of a fake opinion Rule 11 or inherent authority
Loss of admission or removal from the case Wadsworth v. Walmart (D. Wyo. Feb. 24, 2025): the drafting lawyer's pro hac vice status (an out-of-state lawyer's permission to appear in the case) revoked and the lawyer removed as counsel of record. Withers v. City of Aberdeen (N.D. Miss. June 8, 2026): all four lawyers on both sides removed from the case and two barred from the district's courts for two years, as the Mississippi Free Press reported Rule 11 and inherent authority in Wadsworth; not stated in the Withers report
Education and disclosure orders Kaur: proof of a continuing legal education (CLE) course on AI in legal writing. Lnu: two years of sworn statements on AI use with each filing Rule 11(c)(3); Appellate Rule 46(b)(1)(B)
Suspension from a court's bar Lnu: six months from practice before the Ninth Circuit Appellate Rule 46(b)(1)(B), Ninth Circuit Rule 46-2(a)
Referral for discipline Lnu: to the State Bar of California. Whiting: to the chief judge under Local Rule 46. Perez-Castillo: to the Illinois Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission. A Nebraska divorce appeal: to the Counsel for Discipline Court and bar disciplinary rules
Agency discipline Matter of Sethi: six months before the Board, the immigration courts and DHS 8 CFR 1003.102(e), 1003.103

Immigration firms should read the suspension and agency rows closely, because a suspension changes who can appear for their clients.

What Moved a Penalty Up or Down

Most of these orders explain why the court chose its penalty, and the explanations follow a pattern. The table compares what each lawyer did once the errors surfaced with how the court treated it.

Case What the lawyers did once the errors surfaced How the court treated it
Mata (S.D.N.Y. 2023) Did not withdraw the filing after the other side questioned the cases and the court ordered them produced. First acknowledged the chatbot source in a May 25 affidavit, after an order to show cause $5,000 jointly, plus corrective letters
Wadsworth (D. Wyo. 2025) Withdrew the motions the day after the show-cause order, admitted the cases were not real, paid the other side's fees and adopted new policies. The court noted they could have acted sooner Fines of $3,000 and $1,000 each. Firm not sanctioned
Kaur (N.D.N.Y. 2025) Did not address the errors after the government flagged them. Admitted AI use at the June 24 hearing, sought to withdraw the brief and enrolled in an AI ethics course $1,000, below the $1,500 to $15,000 range the court called typical. The court found subjective bad faith and said regret and apologies do not necessarily avoid sanctions
Fletcher (5th Cir. 2026) Blamed public versions of the cases, then paraphrased summaries. Admitted AI use only when asked directly and said it only helped organize arguments. The court did not find that credible $2,500. The court said a forthright response would likely have meant a lighter sanction
Whiting (6th Cir. 2026) Ignored a show-cause order, called it void and accused the court of harassment The other side's fees, double costs, $15,000 each and a referral for discipline
Lnu (9th Cir. 2026) Called the errors typographical and denied AI use at argument and in writing $2,500 each, a six-month suspension, two years of AI statements and a bar referral
Perez-Castillo (7th Cir. 2026) Blamed a lawyer he had contracted to write the brief. Admitted at argument that he had reviewed neither the original nor the revised brief, which still held at least two hallucinated quotes $5,000 fine under Appellate Rule 46(c) and a referral to the Illinois disciplinary commission. The writing attorney was admonished
Dec v. Mullin (7th Cir. 2026), as described in Perez-Castillo Errors in a standard of review section, "presumably copied and pasted" from another brief. The attorney did not misrepresent facts or substantive law, accepted responsibility and apologized Admonished only
Withers (N.D. Miss. 2026), per Mississippi Free Press Two lawyers admitted using AI. The two Mississippi lawyers said they did not use it and signed memoranda without checking sources. The judge credited one lawyer's remediation and the other's self-report to the state bar All four lawyers removed from the case. The judge found bad faith by one out-of-state lawyer and negligence by the two Mississippi lawyers
Omaha attorney's divorce appeal (Neb. Sup. Ct. 2026) Repeatedly denied using AI, according to Nebraska Public Media Briefs rejected and an investigation by the Counsel for Discipline ordered

Mitigation shows most clearly in Kaur. The judge weighed an emergency deadline, illness, an immediate confession and an AI ethics course, and set a fine below the typical range. Heavier outcomes sit with lawyers who denied AI use, called the errors typographical, shifted the blame or ignored the court's questions.

Our reading comes from the written reasons in these orders and is not a formula. Courts weigh other facts too, such as the prior discipline the Sixth Circuit noted for both Whiting lawyers. Candor lowered penalties without erasing them. In Withers, the judge credited remediation and a self-report to the state bar and still removed all four lawyers from the case.

Who Signs, Who Drafts, and Who Pays

Who answered for the filing is the second pattern. In Wadsworth, motions in limine cited nine cases and eight did not exist. The drafting lawyer received the heaviest sanction. A supervising lawyer and local counsel signed without drafting or reviewing the motions and were fined too. Signing carries a nondelegable duty of reasonable inquiry, the judge wrote.

Lnu followed the same logic. Licensed attorneys signed briefs drafted by brief writers who were not licensed. The attorneys had not read the cited cases, and the court sanctioned the signers. In Perez-Castillo, the signer was fined and the contracted writer, who had not entered an appearance, was only admonished. Withers v. City of Aberdeen found both Mississippi local lawyers negligent for signing memoranda without checking the sources.

Firms can answer too. Rule 11(c)(1) makes a firm jointly responsible for violations by its partners, associates or employees absent exceptional circumstances. The Mata court applied that rule. In Wadsworth, the judge declined to sanction the firm. He pointed to its training on the AI software and a new acknowledgment requiring users to verify AI output.

Who Gets Sanctioned, According to the Data

Individual orders show how courts reason, and a dataset shows who appears in them. Riana Pfefferkorn of Stanford's Center for Internet and Society analyzed a snapshot of the AI Hallucination Cases database that ran through October 7, 2025. Her October 2025 analysis counted 114 U.S. cases involving lawyers or paralegals and 160 involving pro se litigants.

Among the 129 firms in the lawyer cases, 50.4 percent were solo practices and 39.5 percent had two to 25 lawyers. Plaintiffs' counsel accounted for 64 of the 114 lawyer cases. The author noted the sample is not comprehensive and went out of date almost at once, so treat the counts as a dated snapshot. By February 18, 2026, the Fifth Circuit reported that the same database had identified 239 cases of hallucination by lawyers in the United States.

For a small firm with no second reviewer, the written check at the end of this guide can sit inside the matter file itself.

Immigration Cases Where Citations Failed

Everything above applies to immigration filings, and three reported matters show how. One came from a deportation habeas petition and two from appeals of removal proceedings.

A Habeas Brief Filed Under Deadline

Petitioner Kaur had been apprehended shortly after crossing the Canadian border and sought to stop her removal. Her lawyer's supplemental brief attributed quotations to four real Supreme Court decisions, and the quoted language does not appear in any of them. The government's brief flagged the errors, and the court found more.

At the June 24, 2025 hearing the lawyer admitted using a generative AI tool. He told the court he had been ill and felt rushed because his client faced imminent deportation. Counsel also acknowledged knowing that AI tools can fabricate citations. Judge Nardacci found subjective bad faith, citing at least conscious avoidance. Details appear in a Northern District of New York Federal Court Bar Association column on the order.

A Petition for Review Before the Ninth Circuit

Attorney Mike Singh Sethi signed a brief in Lnu v. Blanche that cited two nonexistent cases. The briefs also attributed quotations to real opinions that did not contain them, and similar fake citations appeared in two other pending cases.

Judges Paez, Bea and Forrest added duties beyond the fines, suspension and referral listed above. Sethi and attorney William Rounds had to notify clients, opposing counsel and judges in every pending case where they were counsel of record. Their sworn statements on AI use must name the tool and certify personal review of the citations.

The sanctionable conduct included telling the court the errors were typographical or that AI was not involved. Rounds later conceded that AI use was possible.

A Removal Appeal Before the Seventh Circuit

Perez-Castillo v. Blanche, No. 25-1988 (7th Cir. June 1, 2026), was a petition to review a final order of removal. The opening brief contained two dozen fabricated quotations and at least seven nonexistent or mislabeled cases. It also made factual claims the record contradicted, such as hardship to school-age children who were all over 25.

Counsel Abdullah Salah said he had contracted the brief to another attorney, Farah Chalisa, who had not entered an appearance. Chalisa said she used ChatGPT for copyediting. At argument Salah admitted he had reviewed neither the original brief nor the revised one. The revised brief, filed the night before argument, replaced the false citations but kept unsupported statements and at least two hallucinated quotes.

Salah was fined, and the court admonished Chalisa without sanctioning her. It also referred the matter to the Illinois disciplinary commission and kept its show-cause order open until that body reviews it.

How a Suspension Spreads to EOIR and DHS

Suspension is where an immigration lawyer's exposure grows beyond the fines and referrals in most matters above. Two sources explain the path: EOIR's memo on AI and the discipline regulations in 8 CFR part 1003.

What EOIR Has Said About AI

EOIR Policy Memorandum PM 25-40, "Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in EOIR Proceedings," took effect on August 8, 2025. Acting Director Sirce E. Owen signed it. The memo sets no blanket ban and no mandatory disclosure rule, and it allows individual adjudicators and courts to adopt standing orders on AI.

PM 25-40 tells parties to confirm the accuracy of citations in AI-assisted research and drafting. It cites ABA Formal Opinion 512 and lists 8 CFR 1003.102 paragraphs (c), (k) through (o), (s) and (u) as potential grounds for discipline. Among the paragraphs of 8 CFR 1003.102 are these:

  • Paragraph (c) covers knowingly or with reckless disregard making a false statement of material fact or law.
  • Paragraph (n) covers conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice.
  • Paragraph (o) covers failing to provide competent representation.
  • Paragraph (s) covers failing to disclose controlling adverse legal authority.
  • Paragraph (u) covers repeatedly filing documents that show little attention to the facts or law of the case.

How the Reciprocal Route Works

Under 8 CFR 1003.103, EOIR disciplinary counsel can ask the Board of Immigration Appeals to suspend a practitioner immediately. The request can follow a federal court or a state's highest court suspending or disbarring the practitioner. It can also follow a resignation there while under investigation or an interim suspension. DHS can make the same request for practice before DHS.

Disciplinary counsel can rely on a certified copy of the order, which creates a rebuttable presumption of misconduct. The practitioner can rebut it only with clear and convincing evidence of one of these:

  • A due process denial in the first proceeding.
  • Proof too thin for the Board to accept.
  • A grave injustice.

Practitioners must also notify EOIR disciplinary counsel within 30 days of the initial order, even if an appeal is pending. Time spent under an immediate suspension can be credited toward any suspension the Board later imposes.

Matter of Sethi, Step by Step

Matter of Sethi shows the route in practice. The dates below come from the Board's decision.

Date (2026) Event
June 3 The Ninth Circuit suspends Sethi for six months in Lnu v. Blanche, effective June 13
June 15 EOIR and DHS disciplinary counsel file a joint notice of intent to discipline and a joint petition for immediate suspension
July 1 The Board grants the petition and immediately suspends him
July 6 He moves to set aside the immediate suspension
September 15 The Board issues its decision as unpublished: motion denied, summary adjudication granted
October 1 The decision is designated precedent as Matter of Sethi, 30 I&N Dec. 112 (BIA 2026)

Sethi received a six-month suspension from practice before the Board, the immigration courts and DHS, effective June 13, 2026. He may petition for reinstatement under 8 CFR 1003.107.

Reciprocal discipline for AI-related misconduct was unprecedented, Sethi argued. The Board rejected the argument. It held that attorneys must follow conduct rules whatever tools they use. Citing nonexistent cases and making false statements can draw discipline with or without AI.

A Verification Routine Before You Sign

One gap runs through the orders above, a signature on a paper nobody read closely. The routine below puts a check between the draft and the signature. It applies to any filing that AI touched and to any draft a person other than the signer prepared.

  1. Open every cited decision on the court's own site or in an official reporter, and read the passage that supports your point. In Fletcher, the Fifth Circuit found the quoted language nowhere in the CourtListener, Justia or FindLaw summaries the lawyer had named as her sources.
  2. Match every quotation, word for word, to the text of the decision.
  3. Match each proposition to the holding, including the direction of the ruling. One Fletcher citation described a case as reversing a sanction when it had affirmed one.
  4. Confirm that each authority is still good law on the filing date.
  5. Look up the tribunal's standing orders on AI. EOIR's memo allows adjudicators and courts to adopt them.
  6. Read a paralegal's, brief writer's or contract lawyer's draft as if it were your own. The signer answered for it in Wadsworth, Lnu and Perez-Castillo.
  7. Record who verified what in the matter file. The Whiting show-cause order asked who wrote the briefs, whether AI was used and how they were cite-checked.

Lawyers who find an error after filing should report it and ask leave to file a corrected brief, the Fifth Circuit said in Fletcher.

AI Legal Document Drafting fills USCIS forms from intake data, which cuts typing time. Citations and facts still get confirmed at the attorney's check.

Grow Your Caseload With US Immigration AI

US Immigration AI automates the work between client intake and the final filing for licensed immigration firms. A firm can handle more cases with the same team and keep attorney time for judgment calls like the cite-check above. Schedule a demo to see how the workflow runs.

Frequently Asked Questions

No. US Immigration AI is a technology tool and does not provide legal advice. It does not replace attorney judgment or form an attorney-client relationship, and a licensed lawyer reviews every file before submission.

Not directly. Rule 11 governs filings in federal district courts, as in Mata and Kaur, and courts of appeals use Appellate Rule 46, as in Perez-Castillo. Before the Board and the immigration courts, the conduct rules in 8 CFR 1003.102 apply.

Fines are not among the events that start the reciprocal route in 8 CFR 1003.103, so a fine alone does not trigger it. EOIR can still pursue the underlying conduct directly under 8 CFR 1003.102, such as the false-statement ground in paragraph (c).

Check it that day. In Kaur, the government's brief flagged the fabricated quotations, and the lawyer took no action until the court raised them at a hearing. The court treated that inaction as at least conscious avoidance. Wadsworth's judge also noted the lawyers could have acted sooner.

Responsibility stays with the signer. In Wadsworth, the drafting lawyer used what the order describes as an apparent in-house platform launched by his firm, and three lawyers were still fined. Ignorance of AI's risks is no excuse, the Fifth Circuit said in Fletcher.

Yes. In March 2026 the Nebraska Supreme Court listed 20 examples of fictional quotes, wrong case numbers or misstated results in an Omaha attorney's appeal brief. It cited a failure of candor and wrote that AI "must be used with caution and humility."

‍

‍

More Time to Check Every Filing

Our platform handles intake, retainers, document collection and form drafting. See a short walkthrough of how your attorneys keep time for review.